The Watched

Gene Expression
Tim Blair
Scott Ganz
Glenn Reynolds
James Lileks
The Corner
Andrew Sullivan
Little Green Footballs
Stephen Green
Doctor Weevil
Pejman Yousefzadeh
The Anti-Idiotarian Rottweiler

They Like Us

". . . a monumental disappointment."
- Pejman Yousefzadeh

". . . simply pissing in to the wind."
- Weekend Pundit

". . . misguided passivists."
- Craig Schamp

". . . shares Ted Rall's fantasies of oppression."
- Max Powers

". . . pathetic waste of pixels."
- Daily Pundit

" . . . anarcho-leftist cowards."
- DC Thornton

". . . a good read, apart from the odd witchhunt."
- Emmanuel Goldstein

". . . quite insane."
- Richard Bennett

"There's many a boy here today who looks on war as all glory, but, boys, it is all hell." -- General William T. Sherman, Address, 1880

Keep Laughing

White House

(Note to literalists: the Watched column presently contains only a smattering of 'warblogs' because the facilitator of the template-change--Dr. Menlo--is not very familiar with them, and will be adding more as they are sent to him. Also, this blog may contain areas of allusion, satire, subtext, context and possibly even a dash of the surreal: wannabe lit-crits beware.)


[Watch this space for: Pentagon and Petroleum, The Media is only as Liberal as the Corporations Who Own Them, Wash Down With, and Recalcify]


Friday, August 09, 2002


Martin Peretz: Anti-War Fifth-Columnist?

The Israel army’s recent assassination of Salah Shehadeh by means of a one-ton bomb dropped in a crowded residential neighborhood in Gaza City, an action that produced substantial collateral damage, including the deaths of at least 15 innocent civilians, has proved difficult to defend even by the most ardent supporters of Israeli Prime Minister Ariel Sharon and the use of excessive force by the country’s military.

Let it not be said, however, that Martin Peretz couldn’t rise to the challenge, taking to the end page of the August 5 edition of his prized wedding gift, the New Republic, in an effort not only to justify the Israelis’ assault but to contend that the U.S. would have acted similarly, an argument he extends to the point of asserting Israel’s moral superiority over the U.S.

Noting the Bush administration’s half-hearted criticism of the attack, delivered by spokesman Ari Flesicher, (“this heavy-handed action does not contribute to peace”), Peretz writes: “It is true that Fleischer tried to draw a distinction between civilian casualties in the American-led war in Afghanistan and Israel’s bombing in Gaza. But, alas, this comparison does not redound in favor of the United States.”

Peretz cites a July 21 report in the New York Times in which it is asserted that the “American air campaign in Afghanistan, based on a high-tech, out-of-harm’s-way strategy, has produced a pattern of mistakes that have killed hundreds of Afghan civilians.”

The Times cites the U.S. bombing of a mosque last November during which 65 noncombatants were killed. Quoting the Times, Peretz adds: “[T]he evidence suggests that many civilians have been killed by air strikes hitting precisely the target they were aimed at . . . or because . . . Americans did not carefully differentiate between civilians and military targets.”

If true, this is more than carelessness,” Peretz argues. “But let me pose a question,” the polemicist continues. “If we knew Mullah Omar and his men were riding in a convoy with women and children, would we refrain from bombing, even though noncombatants might be killed? I doubt it.” [Emphasis added.]

Is this how Peretz writes about his own country? Is he suggesting that the U.S. military’s operation in Afghanistan is being conducted in manner that lacks 100-percent moral rectitude? Is he accusing the U.S. military of acting with reckless disregard for innocent human lives? Is he suggesting the U.S. has committed war crimes? Is he seeking to undermine public support for the war on terrorism?

As usual, Peretz has much to answer for.

• • • • •

The Watchers

WBW: Keeping track of the war exhortations of the warbloggers.

"Ideas are also weapons."

Amir Butler
A True Word


James Capozzola
The Rittenhouse Review

||| trr |||

Scoobie Davis
Scoobie Davis Online


Roy Edroso

Crank Watch

Eliot Gelwan
Follow Me Here


Green Flash


Jak King
Jak's View Fom Vancouver


Dr. Menlo
American Samizdat
Dr. Menlo Blogs From Space!
Exquisite Corpse
Sensual Liberation Army

Grady Oliver
Like Father Like Sun


Brad Olson
Like Father Like Sun


Philip Shropshire
Three River Tech Review

Dubya Watch

Smarter Sullivan

Warblogger Watch was created by the mysterious freedom fighter Eric A. Blair.

WBW template and additional production assistance by Dr. Menlo, M.D.

WBW Archives

Is WBW your favorite blog? Then send a message to MSNBC's Weblog Central and tell 'em!

They Really Like Us

". . . verve, venom, and a critical eye that would make Rageboy proud."
- A Klog Apart

". . . a great place to keep track of the foam-flecked rantings of the cyber-belligeratti."
- Justin Raimondo

Allies On The Page

Abuddhas Memes
Busy, Busy, Busy
Anil Dash
Douze Lunes
Eve of the Apocalypse
Follow Me Here
Hauser Report
High Water
History News Network
The Hive
Micah Holmquist
Incoming Signals
Interesting Monstah
Kill Your TV
Easter Lemming
Madeleine Kane
Mass Distractions
Nathan Newman
New World Disorder
One Good Move
Reading & Writing
Rittenhouse Review
Stage Left
Suspension of Disbelief
Travelers Diagram

Comrades In Un-Arms

Counterspin Central
Justin Raimondo
Smarter Andrew Sullivan

Powered By Blogger TM

Buds Babes Dicks Gay Porn HD Porn iPod Porn Midget Porn Circus Tranny Crave BBW Chaser Epic Porn Site